Best Italian, Date Night in Maplewood, Nj — Harry's ten

Tell Harry what you fancy. Ten places worth leaving the house for. Harry reads the review-site noise, spots the tourist traps, and hands over a shortlist before the kettle's boiled.

Be honest with him. He doesn't judge.

Places

date-night first

Worth sharing

Send these ten to whoever’s asking where to eat.

Post on X

Sort

Rank 1.
Porta Rossa Pasta & Provisions
italian · food-store · Maplewood
fresh pasta and a solid provisions counter that actually knows what it's doing—this is real italian food, not the usual suspects.
Harry HungryHarry's headline verdict, 0–100. How good the place actually is, once the loud reviews and the timid critics have cancelled each other out.
Worth ItWorth-It Score, 0–100. Whether the bill is fair for what lands on the table. High means good value; low means you're paying for the postcode.
4 min · $$ · ClosedToday · 09:30 — 18:00G5.0TY4.7MS
Google5.0(161)Yelp4.7(23)Tripadvisornot on tripadvisor2/ 3 sources
- Almost nobody's been. The ones who have can't shut up about it. Worth getting in before the crowd finds it.
Warningsmall sample size, so take the hype with a grain of salt.
Call Website Google Yelp Directions Instagram Card
Rank 2.
Giorgio's Restaurant
italian · South Orange Village
consistent italian done right without pretension or inflated prices.
Harry HungryHarry's headline verdict, 0–100. How good the place actually is, once the loud reviews and the timid critics have cancelled each other out.
Worth ItWorth-It Score, 0–100. Whether the bill is fair for what lands on the table. High means good value; low means you're paying for the postcode.
4 min · $$ · Open nowToday · 12:00 — 15:00G4.7T4.3YMSOT5.0
Google4.7(438)Tripadvisor4.3(44)OpenTable5.0(598)Yelpnot on yelp2/ 3 sources
Call Website Google Tripadvisor Directions Instagram Card
Rank 3.
Osteria LK
italian · Maplewood
solid neighborhood italian with real kitchen chops and tripadvisor backing it up.
Harry HungryHarry's headline verdict, 0–100. How good the place actually is, once the loud reviews and the timid critics have cancelled each other out.
Worth ItWorth-It Score, 0–100. Whether the bill is fair for what lands on the table. High means good value; low means you're paying for the postcode.
5 min · $$ · Open nowToday · 11:30 — 15:30G4.6T4.8Y4.5MS
Google4.6(141)Yelp4.5(67)Tripadvisor4.8(12)
- Almost nobody's been. The ones who have can't shut up about it. Worth getting in before the crowd finds it.
Warninglimited reviews, but the ones that exist are legit.
Call Website Google Yelp Tripadvisor Directions Instagram Card
Rank 4.
La Strada
italian · sandwich-shop · Millburn
does sandwiches and italian without trying to be two things at once—focused execution.
Harry HungryHarry's headline verdict, 0–100. How good the place actually is, once the loud reviews and the timid critics have cancelled each other out.
Worth ItWorth-It Score, 0–100. Whether the bill is fair for what lands on the table. High means good value; low means you're paying for the postcode.
5 min · $$ · Open nowToday · 10:00 — 22:00G4.5T4.3YMSFB4.9
Google4.5(542)Tripadvisor4.3(102)Facebook4.9(62)Yelpnot on yelp2/ 3 sources
Call Website Google Tripadvisor Directions Instagram Facebook Card
Rank 5.
Enzzo's Trattoria
italian · pizza · Short Hills
pizza and pasta in one place that doesn't phone it in on either.
Harry HungryHarry's headline verdict, 0–100. How good the place actually is, once the loud reviews and the timid critics have cancelled each other out.
Worth ItWorth-It Score, 0–100. Whether the bill is fair for what lands on the table. High means good value; low means you're paying for the postcode.
7 min · $$ · Open nowToday · 17:00 — 22:00G4.5T4.4Y4.2MS
Google4.5(207)Yelp4.2(104)Tripadvisor4.4(36)
Call Website Google Yelp Tripadvisor Directions Instagram Card
Rank 6.
mozzarella
italian · South Orange Village
google loves it, which usually means the mozzarella is actually fresh.
Harry HungryHarry's headline verdict, 0–100. How good the place actually is, once the loud reviews and the timid critics have cancelled each other out.
Worth ItWorth-It Score, 0–100. Whether the bill is fair for what lands on the table. High means good value; low means you're paying for the postcode.
15 min · $$ · Open nowToday · 11:00 — 22:00G4.7T3.7YMS
Google4.7(1.0k)Tripadvisor3.7(3)Yelpnot on yelp2/ 3 sources
- Google's into it. Tripadvisor isn't. Locals are louder here.
Warningyelp and tripadvisor tell a different story—google might be seeing a different restaurant.
Call Website Google Tripadvisor Directions Instagram Card
Rank 7.
Sofia's Fine Italian Cuisine Restaurant
italian · Springfield
fine dining italian at $$ prices is rare enough to be worth checking out.
Harry HungryHarry's headline verdict, 0–100. How good the place actually is, once the loud reviews and the timid critics have cancelled each other out.
Worth ItWorth-It Score, 0–100. Whether the bill is fair for what lands on the table. High means good value; low means you're paying for the postcode.
7 min · $$ · Open nowToday · 11:30 — 22:00G4.5T3.7YMSFB3.7
Google4.5(548)Tripadvisor3.7(67)Facebook3.7(3)Yelpnot on yelp2/ 3 sources
Call Website Google Tripadvisor Directions Instagram Facebook Card
Rank 8.
La Famiglia Ristorante, Pizzeria & Catering Maplewood
italian · pizza · Maplewood
does catering and delivery without losing the plot on dine-in quality.
Harry HungryHarry's headline verdict, 0–100. How good the place actually is, once the loud reviews and the timid critics have cancelled each other out.
Worth ItWorth-It Score, 0–100. Whether the bill is fair for what lands on the table. High means good value; low means you're paying for the postcode.
4 min · $$ · Open nowToday · 10:45 — 21:00G4.7T1.0YMSOT4.2FB5.0
Google4.7(664)Tripadvisor1.0(1)OpenTable4.2(23)Facebook5.0(3)Yelpnot on yelp2/ 3 sources
- Google's into it. Tripadvisor isn't. Locals are louder here.
Warningtripadvisor gave it a 1—that's a red flag worth investigating before you go.
Call Website Google Tripadvisor Directions Instagram Card
Rank 9.
Mario's Tutto Bene
italian · Union
steady italian spot with consistent reviews across platforms—no surprises, just solid food.
Harry HungryHarry's headline verdict, 0–100. How good the place actually is, once the loud reviews and the timid critics have cancelled each other out.
Worth ItWorth-It Score, 0–100. Whether the bill is fair for what lands on the table. High means good value; low means you're paying for the postcode.
9 min · $$ · Open nowToday · 12:00 — 23:00G4.5T4.0Y4.0MSOT4.1
Google4.5(1.4k)Yelp4.0(280)Tripadvisor4.0(94)OpenTable4.1(34)
Call Website Google Yelp Tripadvisor Directions Instagram Facebook Card
Rank 10.
Village Trattoria
italian · pizza · Maplewood
pizza and pasta neighborhood joint with real staying power in the ratings.
Harry HungryHarry's headline verdict, 0–100. How good the place actually is, once the loud reviews and the timid critics have cancelled each other out.
Worth ItWorth-It Score, 0–100. Whether the bill is fair for what lands on the table. High means good value; low means you're paying for the postcode.
4 min · $$ · Open nowToday · 11:00 — 21:30G4.4T4.0Y4.0MSFB4.7
Google4.4(547)Yelp4.0(163)Tripadvisor4.0(51)Facebook4.7(63)
Call Website Google Yelp Tripadvisor Directions Instagram Facebook Card

Summaries are generated from the available evidence and may be editorially reviewed. They are not direct quotations.

Best Italian, Date Night in Maplewood, Nj — Harry's ten

Tell Harry what you fancy. Ten places worth leaving the house for. Harry reads the review-site noise, spots the tourist traps, and hands over a shortlist before the kettle's boiled.

Be honest with him. He doesn't judge.

Places

date-night first

Worth sharing

Send these ten to whoever’s asking where to eat.

Post on X

Sort

Rank 1.
Porta Rossa Pasta & Provisions
italian · food-store · Maplewood
fresh pasta and a solid provisions counter that actually knows what it's doing—this is real italian food, not the usual suspects.
Harry HungryHarry's headline verdict, 0–100. How good the place actually is, once the loud reviews and the timid critics have cancelled each other out.
Worth ItWorth-It Score, 0–100. Whether the bill is fair for what lands on the table. High means good value; low means you're paying for the postcode.
4 min · $$ · ClosedToday · 09:30 — 18:00G5.0TY4.7MS
Google5.0(161)Yelp4.7(23)Tripadvisornot on tripadvisor2/ 3 sources
- Almost nobody's been. The ones who have can't shut up about it. Worth getting in before the crowd finds it.
Warningsmall sample size, so take the hype with a grain of salt.
Call Website Google Yelp Directions Instagram Card
Rank 2.
Giorgio's Restaurant
italian · South Orange Village
consistent italian done right without pretension or inflated prices.
Harry HungryHarry's headline verdict, 0–100. How good the place actually is, once the loud reviews and the timid critics have cancelled each other out.
Worth ItWorth-It Score, 0–100. Whether the bill is fair for what lands on the table. High means good value; low means you're paying for the postcode.
4 min · $$ · Open nowToday · 12:00 — 15:00G4.7T4.3YMSOT5.0
Google4.7(438)Tripadvisor4.3(44)OpenTable5.0(598)Yelpnot on yelp2/ 3 sources
Call Website Google Tripadvisor Directions Instagram Card
Rank 3.
Osteria LK
italian · Maplewood
solid neighborhood italian with real kitchen chops and tripadvisor backing it up.
Harry HungryHarry's headline verdict, 0–100. How good the place actually is, once the loud reviews and the timid critics have cancelled each other out.
Worth ItWorth-It Score, 0–100. Whether the bill is fair for what lands on the table. High means good value; low means you're paying for the postcode.
5 min · $$ · Open nowToday · 11:30 — 15:30G4.6T4.8Y4.5MS
Google4.6(141)Yelp4.5(67)Tripadvisor4.8(12)
- Almost nobody's been. The ones who have can't shut up about it. Worth getting in before the crowd finds it.
Warninglimited reviews, but the ones that exist are legit.
Call Website Google Yelp Tripadvisor Directions Instagram Card
Rank 4.
La Strada
italian · sandwich-shop · Millburn
does sandwiches and italian without trying to be two things at once—focused execution.
Harry HungryHarry's headline verdict, 0–100. How good the place actually is, once the loud reviews and the timid critics have cancelled each other out.
Worth ItWorth-It Score, 0–100. Whether the bill is fair for what lands on the table. High means good value; low means you're paying for the postcode.
5 min · $$ · Open nowToday · 10:00 — 22:00G4.5T4.3YMSFB4.9
Google4.5(542)Tripadvisor4.3(102)Facebook4.9(62)Yelpnot on yelp2/ 3 sources
Call Website Google Tripadvisor Directions Instagram Facebook Card
Rank 5.
Enzzo's Trattoria
italian · pizza · Short Hills
pizza and pasta in one place that doesn't phone it in on either.
Harry HungryHarry's headline verdict, 0–100. How good the place actually is, once the loud reviews and the timid critics have cancelled each other out.
Worth ItWorth-It Score, 0–100. Whether the bill is fair for what lands on the table. High means good value; low means you're paying for the postcode.
7 min · $$ · Open nowToday · 17:00 — 22:00G4.5T4.4Y4.2MS
Google4.5(207)Yelp4.2(104)Tripadvisor4.4(36)
Call Website Google Yelp Tripadvisor Directions Instagram Card
Rank 6.
mozzarella
italian · South Orange Village
google loves it, which usually means the mozzarella is actually fresh.
Harry HungryHarry's headline verdict, 0–100. How good the place actually is, once the loud reviews and the timid critics have cancelled each other out.
Worth ItWorth-It Score, 0–100. Whether the bill is fair for what lands on the table. High means good value; low means you're paying for the postcode.
15 min · $$ · Open nowToday · 11:00 — 22:00G4.7T3.7YMS
Google4.7(1.0k)Tripadvisor3.7(3)Yelpnot on yelp2/ 3 sources
- Google's into it. Tripadvisor isn't. Locals are louder here.
Warningyelp and tripadvisor tell a different story—google might be seeing a different restaurant.
Call Website Google Tripadvisor Directions Instagram Card
Rank 7.
Sofia's Fine Italian Cuisine Restaurant
italian · Springfield
fine dining italian at $$ prices is rare enough to be worth checking out.
Harry HungryHarry's headline verdict, 0–100. How good the place actually is, once the loud reviews and the timid critics have cancelled each other out.
Worth ItWorth-It Score, 0–100. Whether the bill is fair for what lands on the table. High means good value; low means you're paying for the postcode.
7 min · $$ · Open nowToday · 11:30 — 22:00G4.5T3.7YMSFB3.7
Google4.5(548)Tripadvisor3.7(67)Facebook3.7(3)Yelpnot on yelp2/ 3 sources
Call Website Google Tripadvisor Directions Instagram Facebook Card
Rank 8.
La Famiglia Ristorante, Pizzeria & Catering Maplewood
italian · pizza · Maplewood
does catering and delivery without losing the plot on dine-in quality.
Harry HungryHarry's headline verdict, 0–100. How good the place actually is, once the loud reviews and the timid critics have cancelled each other out.
Worth ItWorth-It Score, 0–100. Whether the bill is fair for what lands on the table. High means good value; low means you're paying for the postcode.
4 min · $$ · Open nowToday · 10:45 — 21:00G4.7T1.0YMSOT4.2FB5.0
Google4.7(664)Tripadvisor1.0(1)OpenTable4.2(23)Facebook5.0(3)Yelpnot on yelp2/ 3 sources
- Google's into it. Tripadvisor isn't. Locals are louder here.
Warningtripadvisor gave it a 1—that's a red flag worth investigating before you go.
Call Website Google Tripadvisor Directions Instagram Card
Rank 9.
Mario's Tutto Bene
italian · Union
steady italian spot with consistent reviews across platforms—no surprises, just solid food.
Harry HungryHarry's headline verdict, 0–100. How good the place actually is, once the loud reviews and the timid critics have cancelled each other out.
Worth ItWorth-It Score, 0–100. Whether the bill is fair for what lands on the table. High means good value; low means you're paying for the postcode.
9 min · $$ · Open nowToday · 12:00 — 23:00G4.5T4.0Y4.0MSOT4.1
Google4.5(1.4k)Yelp4.0(280)Tripadvisor4.0(94)OpenTable4.1(34)
Call Website Google Yelp Tripadvisor Directions Instagram Facebook Card
Rank 10.
Village Trattoria
italian · pizza · Maplewood
pizza and pasta neighborhood joint with real staying power in the ratings.
Harry HungryHarry's headline verdict, 0–100. How good the place actually is, once the loud reviews and the timid critics have cancelled each other out.
Worth ItWorth-It Score, 0–100. Whether the bill is fair for what lands on the table. High means good value; low means you're paying for the postcode.
4 min · $$ · Open nowToday · 11:00 — 21:30G4.4T4.0Y4.0MSFB4.7
Google4.4(547)Yelp4.0(163)Tripadvisor4.0(51)Facebook4.7(63)
Call Website Google Yelp Tripadvisor Directions Instagram Facebook Card

Summaries are generated from the available evidence and may be editorially reviewed. They are not direct quotations.

Best Italian, Date Night in Maplewood, Nj — Harry's ten

Porta Rossa Pasta & Provisions

Giorgio's Restaurant

Osteria LK

La Strada

Enzzo's Trattoria

mozzarella

Sofia's Fine Italian Cuisine Restaurant

La Famiglia Ristorante, Pizzeria & Catering Maplewood

Mario's Tutto Bene

Village Trattoria

Best Italian, Date Night in Maplewood, Nj — Harry's ten

Porta Rossa Pasta & Provisions

Giorgio's Restaurant

Osteria LK

La Strada

Enzzo's Trattoria

mozzarella

Sofia's Fine Italian Cuisine Restaurant

La Famiglia Ristorante, Pizzeria & Catering Maplewood

Mario's Tutto Bene

Village Trattoria