Best Halal Pizza Bay Ridge in 11209 — Harry's ten

Tell Harry what you fancy. Ten places worth leaving the house for. Harry reads the review-site noise, spots the tourist traps, and hands over a shortlist before the kettle's boiled.

Be honest with him. He doesn't judge.

Places

by overall quality

Worth sharing

Send these ten to whoever’s asking where to eat.

Post on X

Sort

Rank 1.
Mello Bistro
bistro · italian · Staten Island
5.0 across 227 Google reviews, and Yelp lands in the same place; priced about right for what you get.
Harry HungryHarry's headline verdict, 0–100. How good the place actually is, once the loud reviews and the timid critics have cancelled each other out.
Worth ItWorth-It Score, 0–100. Whether the bill is fair for what lands on the table. High means good value; low means you're paying for the postcode.
14693 min · $$ · Open nowToday · 17:00 — 23:00G5.0T4.6Y4.8MS
Google5.0(227)Yelp4.8(46)Tripadvisor4.6(5)
- Almost nobody's been. The ones who have can't shut up about it. Worth getting in before the crowd finds it.
Call Website Google Yelp Tripadvisor Directions Instagram Facebook Card
Rank 2.
Emilio’s Wood Fire Pizza
pizza · Nutley
4.8 across 390 Google reviews, and Yelp lands in the same place; ranked #28 of 84 locally on Tripadvisor.
Harry HungryHarry's headline verdict, 0–100. How good the place actually is, once the loud reviews and the timid critics have cancelled each other out.
Worth ItWorth-It Score, 0–100. Whether the bill is fair for what lands on the table. High means good value; low means you're paying for the postcode.
14712 min · $$ · Open nowToday · 15:00 — 22:00G4.8TY4.8MS
Google4.8(390)Yelp4.8(125)Tripadvisornot on tripadvisor2/ 3 sources
Call Website Google Yelp Directions Instagram Facebook Card
Rank 3.
Lo Duca Pizza
pizza · Brooklyn
4.8 across 780 Google reviews, and Yelp lands in the same place; unusually good for what you'll pay.
Harry HungryHarry's headline verdict, 0–100. How good the place actually is, once the loud reviews and the timid critics have cancelled each other out.
Worth ItWorth-It Score, 0–100. Whether the bill is fair for what lands on the table. High means good value; low means you're paying for the postcode.
14679 min · $ · ClosedToday · 11:00 — 21:00G4.8TY4.5MSFB5.0
Google4.8(780)Yelp4.5(185)Facebook5.0(33)Tripadvisornot on tripadvisor2/ 3 sources
Call Website Google Yelp Tripadvisor Directions Instagram Facebook Card
Rank 4.
Jaan’s Pizza
pizza · Old Bridge
4.8 across 479 Google reviews, and Yelp lands in the same place; fairly priced for what it is.
Harry HungryHarry's headline verdict, 0–100. How good the place actually is, once the loud reviews and the timid critics have cancelled each other out.
Worth ItWorth-It Score, 0–100. Whether the bill is fair for what lands on the table. High means good value; low means you're paying for the postcode.
14719 min · $$ · Open nowToday · 11:30 — 22:00G4.8TY4.6MS
Google4.8(479)Yelp4.6(21)Tripadvisornot on tripadvisor2/ 3 sources
Call Website Google Yelp Directions Instagram Card
Rank 5.
The Astarita
pizza · meal-takeaway · Brooklyn
4.7 across 225 Google reviews, and Yelp lands in the same place; OpenTable diners back it up at 3.7.
Harry HungryHarry's headline verdict, 0–100. How good the place actually is, once the loud reviews and the timid critics have cancelled each other out.
Worth ItWorth-It Score, 0–100. Whether the bill is fair for what lands on the table. High means good value; low means you're paying for the postcode.
14685 min · $$ · Open nowToday · 11:30 — 22:00G4.7TY4.8MSOT3.7
Google4.7(225)Yelp4.8(41)OpenTable3.7(2)Tripadvisornot on tripadvisor2/ 3 sources
- Almost nobody's been. The ones who have can't shut up about it. Worth getting in before the crowd finds it.
Call Website Google Yelp Directions Instagram Card
Rank 6.
Terina
italian · Brooklyn
4.9 across 317 Google reviews; priced about right for what you get.
Harry HungryHarry's headline verdict, 0–100. How good the place actually is, once the loud reviews and the timid critics have cancelled each other out.
Worth ItWorth-It Score, 0–100. Whether the bill is fair for what lands on the table. High means good value; low means you're paying for the postcode.
14688 min · $$ · Open nowToday · 12:00 — 00:00G4.9TY4.5MS
Google4.9(317)Yelp4.5(40)Tripadvisornot on tripadvisor2/ 3 sources
- Almost nobody's been. The ones who have can't shut up about it. Worth getting in before the crowd finds it.
- A flawless score with barely anything to check it against. Harry's cautious of 5.0s that haven't been tested yet.
WarningA flawless score with barely anything to check it against. Harry's cautious of 5.0s that haven't been tested yet.
Call Website Google Yelp Directions Instagram · 22K Card
Rank 7.
Baciccia
italian · pizza · Brooklyn
4.7 across 381 Google reviews, and Yelp lands in the same place; warm, snug eatery with brick-clad walls offering Italian dishes & pies with creative….
Harry HungryHarry's headline verdict, 0–100. How good the place actually is, once the loud reviews and the timid critics have cancelled each other out.
Worth ItWorth-It Score, 0–100. Whether the bill is fair for what lands on the table. High means good value; low means you're paying for the postcode.
14683 min · $$ · Open nowToday · 17:00 — 22:00G4.7T4.8Y4.5MS
Google4.7(381)Yelp4.5(180)Tripadvisor4.8(21)
Call Website Google Yelp Tripadvisor Directions Instagram Card
Rank 8.
Little Pizza Parlor
pizza · pizza-delivery · Brooklyn
4.7 across 1.0k Google reviews, and Yelp lands in the same place; ranked #333 of 7,760 locally on Tripadvisor.
Harry HungryHarry's headline verdict, 0–100. How good the place actually is, once the loud reviews and the timid critics have cancelled each other out.
Worth ItWorth-It Score, 0–100. Whether the bill is fair for what lands on the table. High means good value; low means you're paying for the postcode.
14684 min · $ · Open nowToday · 11:00 — 03:00G4.7TY4.5MS
Google4.7(1.0k)Yelp4.5(194)Tripadvisornot on tripadvisor2/ 3 sources
Call Website Google Yelp Tripadvisor Directions Instagram Card
Rank 9.
Aromi
italian · pizza · Brooklyn
4.9 across 796 Google reviews, and Yelp lands in the same place; ranked #899 of 7,760 locally on Tripadvisor.
Harry HungryHarry's headline verdict, 0–100. How good the place actually is, once the loud reviews and the timid critics have cancelled each other out.
Worth ItWorth-It Score, 0–100. Whether the bill is fair for what lands on the table. High means good value; low means you're paying for the postcode.
14685 min · $$ · Open nowToday · 17:00 — 22:30G4.9TY4.6MS
Google4.9(796)Yelp4.6(97)Tripadvisornot on tripadvisor2/ 3 sources
- A flawless score with barely anything to check it against. Harry's cautious of 5.0s that haven't been tested yet.
WarningA flawless score with barely anything to check it against. Harry's cautious of 5.0s that haven't been tested yet.
Call Website Google Yelp Tripadvisor Directions Instagram Card
Rank 10.
OLIO E PIÙ
italian · New York
4.7 across 12k Google reviews, and Yelp lands in the same place; naples meets NYC at this trattoria with thin-crust pizza, Italian wines & ample….
Harry HungryHarry's headline verdict, 0–100. How good the place actually is, once the loud reviews and the timid critics have cancelled each other out.
Worth ItWorth-It Score, 0–100. Whether the bill is fair for what lands on the table. High means good value; low means you're paying for the postcode.
14688 min · $$ · Open nowToday · 11:00 — 00:00G4.7TY4.4MS
Google4.7(12k)Yelp4.4(7.4k)Tripadvisornot on tripadvisor2/ 3 sources
Call Website Google Yelp Tripadvisor Directions Instagram · 70K Card

Also considered

Close, but not on the list — and why.

Summaries are generated from the available evidence and may be editorially reviewed. They are not direct quotations.

Best Halal Pizza Bay Ridge in 11209 — Harry's ten

Tell Harry what you fancy. Ten places worth leaving the house for. Harry reads the review-site noise, spots the tourist traps, and hands over a shortlist before the kettle's boiled.

Be honest with him. He doesn't judge.

Places

by overall quality

Worth sharing

Send these ten to whoever’s asking where to eat.

Post on X

Sort

Rank 1.
Mello Bistro
bistro · italian · Staten Island
5.0 across 227 Google reviews, and Yelp lands in the same place; priced about right for what you get.
Harry HungryHarry's headline verdict, 0–100. How good the place actually is, once the loud reviews and the timid critics have cancelled each other out.
Worth ItWorth-It Score, 0–100. Whether the bill is fair for what lands on the table. High means good value; low means you're paying for the postcode.
14693 min · $$ · Open nowToday · 17:00 — 23:00G5.0T4.6Y4.8MS
Google5.0(227)Yelp4.8(46)Tripadvisor4.6(5)
- Almost nobody's been. The ones who have can't shut up about it. Worth getting in before the crowd finds it.
Call Website Google Yelp Tripadvisor Directions Instagram Facebook Card
Rank 2.
Emilio’s Wood Fire Pizza
pizza · Nutley
4.8 across 390 Google reviews, and Yelp lands in the same place; ranked #28 of 84 locally on Tripadvisor.
Harry HungryHarry's headline verdict, 0–100. How good the place actually is, once the loud reviews and the timid critics have cancelled each other out.
Worth ItWorth-It Score, 0–100. Whether the bill is fair for what lands on the table. High means good value; low means you're paying for the postcode.
14712 min · $$ · Open nowToday · 15:00 — 22:00G4.8TY4.8MS
Google4.8(390)Yelp4.8(125)Tripadvisornot on tripadvisor2/ 3 sources
Call Website Google Yelp Directions Instagram Facebook Card
Rank 3.
Lo Duca Pizza
pizza · Brooklyn
4.8 across 780 Google reviews, and Yelp lands in the same place; unusually good for what you'll pay.
Harry HungryHarry's headline verdict, 0–100. How good the place actually is, once the loud reviews and the timid critics have cancelled each other out.
Worth ItWorth-It Score, 0–100. Whether the bill is fair for what lands on the table. High means good value; low means you're paying for the postcode.
14679 min · $ · ClosedToday · 11:00 — 21:00G4.8TY4.5MSFB5.0
Google4.8(780)Yelp4.5(185)Facebook5.0(33)Tripadvisornot on tripadvisor2/ 3 sources
Call Website Google Yelp Tripadvisor Directions Instagram Facebook Card
Rank 4.
Jaan’s Pizza
pizza · Old Bridge
4.8 across 479 Google reviews, and Yelp lands in the same place; fairly priced for what it is.
Harry HungryHarry's headline verdict, 0–100. How good the place actually is, once the loud reviews and the timid critics have cancelled each other out.
Worth ItWorth-It Score, 0–100. Whether the bill is fair for what lands on the table. High means good value; low means you're paying for the postcode.
14719 min · $$ · Open nowToday · 11:30 — 22:00G4.8TY4.6MS
Google4.8(479)Yelp4.6(21)Tripadvisornot on tripadvisor2/ 3 sources
Call Website Google Yelp Directions Instagram Card
Rank 5.
The Astarita
pizza · meal-takeaway · Brooklyn
4.7 across 225 Google reviews, and Yelp lands in the same place; OpenTable diners back it up at 3.7.
Harry HungryHarry's headline verdict, 0–100. How good the place actually is, once the loud reviews and the timid critics have cancelled each other out.
Worth ItWorth-It Score, 0–100. Whether the bill is fair for what lands on the table. High means good value; low means you're paying for the postcode.
14685 min · $$ · Open nowToday · 11:30 — 22:00G4.7TY4.8MSOT3.7
Google4.7(225)Yelp4.8(41)OpenTable3.7(2)Tripadvisornot on tripadvisor2/ 3 sources
- Almost nobody's been. The ones who have can't shut up about it. Worth getting in before the crowd finds it.
Call Website Google Yelp Directions Instagram Card
Rank 6.
Terina
italian · Brooklyn
4.9 across 317 Google reviews; priced about right for what you get.
Harry HungryHarry's headline verdict, 0–100. How good the place actually is, once the loud reviews and the timid critics have cancelled each other out.
Worth ItWorth-It Score, 0–100. Whether the bill is fair for what lands on the table. High means good value; low means you're paying for the postcode.
14688 min · $$ · Open nowToday · 12:00 — 00:00G4.9TY4.5MS
Google4.9(317)Yelp4.5(40)Tripadvisornot on tripadvisor2/ 3 sources
- Almost nobody's been. The ones who have can't shut up about it. Worth getting in before the crowd finds it.
- A flawless score with barely anything to check it against. Harry's cautious of 5.0s that haven't been tested yet.
WarningA flawless score with barely anything to check it against. Harry's cautious of 5.0s that haven't been tested yet.
Call Website Google Yelp Directions Instagram · 22K Card
Rank 7.
Baciccia
italian · pizza · Brooklyn
4.7 across 381 Google reviews, and Yelp lands in the same place; warm, snug eatery with brick-clad walls offering Italian dishes & pies with creative….
Harry HungryHarry's headline verdict, 0–100. How good the place actually is, once the loud reviews and the timid critics have cancelled each other out.
Worth ItWorth-It Score, 0–100. Whether the bill is fair for what lands on the table. High means good value; low means you're paying for the postcode.
14683 min · $$ · Open nowToday · 17:00 — 22:00G4.7T4.8Y4.5MS
Google4.7(381)Yelp4.5(180)Tripadvisor4.8(21)
Call Website Google Yelp Tripadvisor Directions Instagram Card
Rank 8.
Little Pizza Parlor
pizza · pizza-delivery · Brooklyn
4.7 across 1.0k Google reviews, and Yelp lands in the same place; ranked #333 of 7,760 locally on Tripadvisor.
Harry HungryHarry's headline verdict, 0–100. How good the place actually is, once the loud reviews and the timid critics have cancelled each other out.
Worth ItWorth-It Score, 0–100. Whether the bill is fair for what lands on the table. High means good value; low means you're paying for the postcode.
14684 min · $ · Open nowToday · 11:00 — 03:00G4.7TY4.5MS
Google4.7(1.0k)Yelp4.5(194)Tripadvisornot on tripadvisor2/ 3 sources
Call Website Google Yelp Tripadvisor Directions Instagram Card
Rank 9.
Aromi
italian · pizza · Brooklyn
4.9 across 796 Google reviews, and Yelp lands in the same place; ranked #899 of 7,760 locally on Tripadvisor.
Harry HungryHarry's headline verdict, 0–100. How good the place actually is, once the loud reviews and the timid critics have cancelled each other out.
Worth ItWorth-It Score, 0–100. Whether the bill is fair for what lands on the table. High means good value; low means you're paying for the postcode.
14685 min · $$ · Open nowToday · 17:00 — 22:30G4.9TY4.6MS
Google4.9(796)Yelp4.6(97)Tripadvisornot on tripadvisor2/ 3 sources
- A flawless score with barely anything to check it against. Harry's cautious of 5.0s that haven't been tested yet.
WarningA flawless score with barely anything to check it against. Harry's cautious of 5.0s that haven't been tested yet.
Call Website Google Yelp Tripadvisor Directions Instagram Card
Rank 10.
OLIO E PIÙ
italian · New York
4.7 across 12k Google reviews, and Yelp lands in the same place; naples meets NYC at this trattoria with thin-crust pizza, Italian wines & ample….
Harry HungryHarry's headline verdict, 0–100. How good the place actually is, once the loud reviews and the timid critics have cancelled each other out.
Worth ItWorth-It Score, 0–100. Whether the bill is fair for what lands on the table. High means good value; low means you're paying for the postcode.
14688 min · $$ · Open nowToday · 11:00 — 00:00G4.7TY4.4MS
Google4.7(12k)Yelp4.4(7.4k)Tripadvisornot on tripadvisor2/ 3 sources
Call Website Google Yelp Tripadvisor Directions Instagram · 70K Card

Also considered

Close, but not on the list — and why.

Summaries are generated from the available evidence and may be editorially reviewed. They are not direct quotations.

Best Halal Pizza Bay Ridge in 11209 — Harry's ten

Mello Bistro

Emilio’s Wood Fire PizzaH★

Lo Duca Pizza

Jaan’s Pizza

The Astarita

Terina

Baciccia

Little Pizza Parlor

Aromi

OLIO E PIÙ

Also considered

Best Halal Pizza Bay Ridge in 11209 — Harry's ten

Mello Bistro

Emilio’s Wood Fire PizzaH★

Lo Duca Pizza

Jaan’s Pizza

The Astarita

Terina

Baciccia

Little Pizza Parlor

Aromi

OLIO E PIÙ

Also considered

Emilio’s Wood Fire Pizza

Emilio’s Wood Fire Pizza